Go back
Go back
St. Agrestis hero
Phony Mezcal Negroni SFWSC Double Gold and 98 points 2025 award badge
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
St. Agrestis hero
Phony Mezcal Negroni SFWSC Double Gold and 98 points 2025 award badge
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.
Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni.

Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni

The smoky one, dealt over scopa.
4.8 average · 131 reviews
N° 002 The smoky one 200ml / 6.76oz30 botanicalsGreenpoint, Brooklyn
$64.99 USD
Earn Double Points with PHONY Club

Flavor

Non-Alcoholic Phony Negroni®. Classic Negroni Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni. Mezcal Negroni Non-Alcoholic Phony Espresso Negroni®. Espresso Negroni Non-Alcoholic Amaro Falso®. Amaro Falso Non-Alcoholic Phony White Negroni. White Negroni LIMITED RELEASE Non-Alcoholic Phony Limone Negroni. Limone Negroni
Material Bottles
Pack Size 12-pack
Double Gold2025
Best in Class Nominee2025
DESCRIPTION

Our award-winning, ready-to-serve St. Agrestis Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni is made with 30 real, raw, non-GMO ingredients. With emphasized mezcal qualities, expect vegetal complexity and earthiness.

Perfectly balanced with the bitter foundation of our award-winning Phony Negroni®, enjoy the smoke with none of the booze.

Key botanicals

Smoke Citrus Peel Gentian Root
Phony ClubNew releases first · free shipping on every order · double pointsJoin →
HOW TO SERVE

Made ready-to-serve, simply pour into a rocks glass over ice, or enjoy from the bottle anywhere.
TASTING NOTES

Our award-winning, ready-to-serve St. Agrestis Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni is made with 30 real, raw, non-GMO ingredients. With emphasized mezcal qualities, expect vegetal complexity and earthiness.

Perfectly balanced with the bitter foundation of our award-winning Phony Negroni®, enjoy the smoke with none of the booze.
INGREDIENTS & NUTRITION FACTS
Phony Mezcal Negroni nutrition facts and ingredients
SHIPPING & PACKAGING INFORMATION
  • Free shipping on contiguous US orders over $100
  • US Flat Rate Shipping $5
  • International shipping available to Canada & United Kingdom with shipping and duties calculated at checkout
  • Lightweight, eco-friendly shipping packaging
  • All of our packaging is plastic-free and recyclable
  • 2022-2024 SFWSC BEST-IN-CLASS
  • A True Cocktail Dupe
  • bittersweet
  • complex flavors
  • non-alcoholic, full flavor
  • ready-to-serve
  • 2022-2024 SFWSC BEST-IN-CLASS
  • A True Cocktail Dupe
  • bittersweet
  • complex flavors
  • non-alcoholic, full flavor
  • ready-to-serve

“The contrasts between bitter, sweet, and smoke take Agrestis’s single-serving bottles to new heights.”

BON APPÉTIT

First access, always

Phony Club gets everything first

Members get access to new releases first, plus free shipping on every order & double loyalty points

Join Phony Club

Frequently Asked Questions

WHAT INGREDIENTS DO YOU USE?

All of our non-alcoholic cocktails are made using real, raw non-GMO organic botanicals from five continents across the world.

While we do not highlight each 'natural flavor' ingredient to protect our full recipe, these botanicals fall within three core categories: floral, citrus & bitter.

While our products do contain sugar, we only use organic cane sugar from the Caribbean, which allows us to perfectly balance the cocktail and adds a silky texture on the palette that cocktail drinkers expect.

WHAT MAKES ST. AGRESTIS DIFFERENT THAN OTHER BRANDS?

At St. Agrestis we believe the best way to predict the future is to create it.

Our approach is rooted in ancient methods, designed for the modern world. With over a decade of alcohol distillation experience and proprietary innovation, we develop and produce world class Italian-inspired spirits and non-alcoholic cocktails that honor tradition while embracing disruption.

For our Phony line of non-alcoholic cocktails, our process allows us to maintain all of the flavors, aromas, color and mouthfeel of a proper cocktail, and not with dealcoholizing.

With a precision focus on every ingredient, every connection, and every detail in the pursuit of perfection, St. Agrestis is made for the modern drinker.

WHERE DOES ST. AGRESTIS PRODUCE THEIR PRODUCTS?

All St. Agrestis non-alcoholic cocktails and spirited drinks are developed and produced at our Greenpoint, Brooklyn distillery.

WHAT ARE THE DIFFERENT SHIPPING OPTIONS AVAILABLE?

Free shipping over$100

Shipping available to all 50 U.S. states, Canada and UK

CAN I DRINK YOUR NON-ALCOHOLIC COCKTAILS IF I AM PREGNANT?

Our non-alcoholic products are designed without alcohol, but we cannot provide medical advice. If you are pregnant, nursing, or in recovery, please consult your healthcare provider before consuming.

ARE COCKTAILS NUT-FREE, GULTEN-FREE, NON-GMO & VEGAN?

Our non-alcoholic products and many spirits do not contain gluten ingredients. If you have a severe allergy or intolerance, please consult your doctor before consuming.

Further, we produce all beverages in-house without exposure to nut products or animal-derived ingredients or filtration methods.

Always refer to the ingredient list on the bottle or product page for the most accurate, up-to-date information.

Overall rating: 4.7862597 / 5 from 131 reviews.

AI Generated Review Summary

Customers highly appreciate the Non-Alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni for its excellent taste and as a top non-alcoholic alternative to the traditional Negroni. Many consider it their favorite non-alcoholic drink and the best cocktail on the market.

Summary topics

  • Negroni: 13%
  • Non-Alcoholic Drink: 12%
  • Non-Alcoholic Alternative: 15%
  • Non-Alcoholic Cocktail: 11%

Review topics: ["taste","drink","substitute","work","order","negroni","cocktail","alternative","mocktail","beverage","notes","smokiness","option","sipper","replacement","version","non-alcoholic option","january","water"].

Review highlights

  • "The smoky flavor is so perfect and the balance of sweet and bitter is close to ideal." — Afc N.
  • "I love Phony Negroni—especially the non-alcoholic Phony Mezcal Negroni!" — Cathline M.
  • "The Phony Mezcal Negroni is somehow able to evoke the smoky mezcal taste!" — Bisbee

Reviews

THE ORIGINAL PHONY

"St. Agrestis' Phony Negronis are the best on the market. I love and still drink real Negronis, so the Phony allows me to have more of my favorite cocktail. I will often follow a real drink with a Phony, and the side-by-side comparison is convincing. I always, always go all the way using a great glass, a large cube of ice, and fresh orange peel. My friends try different off-the-shelf brands and share their experiences with me, but they never compare to the original. It makes me think they don’t love Negronis in the first place."

— David S. (5/5)

To quote Bono (sort of)- even better than the real thing

"I’ve been on a sober curious bender of late and acting upon a recommendation from a trusted source I purchased a couple of packs of the regular phoney and the Mezcal phoney. I expected them to be decent but upon tasting I was blown away by them both. As Bono never said, keep on keeping on St. A!"

— Dan M. (5/5)

Amazing!

"We've now tried each of the phonies and they are anything but!!! In short, they are a mind-blowing new product that leaves you with one major conclusion -- who needs alcohol!"

— Glenn T. (5/5)

Mezcal Negroni

"Amazing. The only thing that I’ve found that feels like you are having a real cocktail. Sometimes I wish it were a little smokier and a touch less sweet. But I LOVE it!!!’"

— Pamela S. (5/5)

my go-to sober cocktail.

"literally ordered a case as soon as I sipped a Mezcal Phony Negroni. I was a cocktail and wine enthusiast for two decades and when I had to get sober, I was sorely disappointed in all the NA options. this drink tastes so much like a mezcal negroni, it makes me so happy! and doesn't make me hungover!"

— Rachel S. (5/5)

Great Drink

"Always my favorite. Go NYC!"

— Matt C. (5/5)

Not mezcal

"I love mezcal and was particularly excited about this one. I used to work in the spirits industry with several trips to Mexico every year. That being said, this unfortunately misses the mark in my opinion. It tastes like a mix between antiseptic throat spray and barbecue sauce, but not actually mezcal. Shame. I really thought this one was going to be awesome."

— Stephanie (1/5)

Best mocktail ever

"Best mocktail ever."

— Katherine D. (5/5)

Phony Mezcal Negroni

"A friend introduced me to this drink, his favorite. I really liked the flavor. It taste so much like the “regular” one. Delicious!"

— ANN B. (5/5)

A variation worth trying

"I tried this variety and I am a fan."

— Nomee A. (5/5)

Q&A

Other Favorites
View all